(in)significance: a discussion about values and valuing in heritage
Resources from the (in)significance Symposium held at the University of Canberra on 15th May 2015
The one-day symposium comprised of short presentations and themed panel discussions, with ample opportunities for participation and debate. Many of Australia's leading heritage researchers, teachers and practitioners participated from diverse fields including museums, libraries and archives, archaeology, digital humanities, conservation and heritage studies. The symposium appealed to those with an interest in critical heritage studies and reflective heritage practice and postgraduate students.
Speakers: Steve Brown, Kristal Buckley, Veronica Bullock, Denis Byrne, Adam Dickerson, Ursula Frederick, Bronwyn Hanna, Jane Harrington, Geoff Hinchcliffe, Tracy Ireland, Angelina Russo, Tim Sherratt, Robyn Slogett, Laurajane Smith, Sharon Sullivan, Alison Wain, Tim Winter and Linda Young.
Conveners: Tracy Ireland and Steve Brown
The notion of 'significance' is a central concept for heritage conservation in many parts of the world—it describes what the institutions of heritage choose to remember and what they choose to forget. Used in American historic preservation legislation from the late 19th century, and in the 1964 Venice Charter, in Australia the Burra Charter (Australia ICOMOS 1979) introduced the phrase 'places of cultural significance', a concept that emphasised meanings over monuments.
Determining significance is a process of ascribing values – culturally constructed meanings or qualities attributed by individuals and groups to a heritage object, place or landscape. Valuing heritage has led to practices that typically list, rank and then privilege particular values – at world, national and local levels.
At the symposium we explored the history, theory and practical application of the concept of significance and broach the idea of insignificance.
The following presentations are a selection of presentations from the Symposium.
- Adam Dickerson - Significance for Whom? (PDF 400 KB)
- Alison Wain - Heritage Communities (PDF 940 KB)
- Bronwyn Hanna - insignificance (PDF 229 KB)
- Denis Byrne - Significance and the Supernatural (PDF 268 KB)
- Kristal Buckley - Nature + Culture ( 7532 KB)
- Laurajane Smith and Gary Campbell - Tautology ( PDF 294 KB)
- Linda Young - Grappling (PDF 737 KB)
- Steve Brown - Reduced to Insignificance (PDF 479 KB)
The following summary is not a verbatim transcript. Rather, the notes are a series of statements that seek to capture what was expressed and discussed. The notes are not intended for direct quotation in a scholarly sense, but rather they provide a flavour of the discussions.
- Session 1 Notes (PDF 664 KB)
- Session 2 Notes (PDF 623 KB)
- Session 3 Notes (PDF 619 KB)
- Session 4 Notes (PDF 638 KB)
(in)significance image by: Katie Hayne and Ursula Frederick